top of page

Federal court affirms prior ruling favoring Dare sheriff and deputy in 2023 shooting. Attorney for daughter of murdered Manteo man says they will appeal again

Two photos, one of a man alone and one of him with young women, are displayed next to lit candles

Photos of Sylvester Demetrius Selby alone and with his daughters are displayed at Cartwright Park in Manteo during his vigil on Oct. 3, 2023, the evening after he died following a law enforcement encounter in which he was shot three times. According to a medical examiner’s report, Selby’s manner of death was homicide by a pocketknife stab wound to the chest, with two gunshot wounds to the torso as “contributing conditions,” and both a handgun and a pocketknife were listed as his “means of death.” (Photo by Corinne Saunders)


By Corinne Saunders


Editor’s Note: This article is exclusive to paid subscribers of Outer Banks Insider. To read this story, subscribe today at the button below (active subscribers need only log in).


The United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit on Tuesday upheld a prior district court decision to dismiss the lawsuit against the Dare County sheriff and a deputy. The lawsuit challenged the use of force in a 2023 encounter that ended with the death of a Manteo man, and the lawyer for the daughter of the deceased shared plans to again appeal.

Want to read more?

Subscribe to outerbanksnews.org to keep reading this exclusive post.

Outer Banks Insider is fiscally sponsored by the Alternative Newsweekly Foundation, EIN 30-
0100369. All donations are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.

bottom of page